skip navigation

How the USL is helping a group of young English talents chase their American dream

By NICHOLAS MURRAY - nicholas.murray@uslsoccer.com, 12/03/24, 8:25AM EST

Share

Former Scholars from EFL clubs will compete at USL Academy League Finals with professional aspirations front of mind


A new partnership between the USL and the English Football League and League Football Education (LFE) has broughta collection of other former EFL Scholars to Florida this month. | Photo courtesy Gianmarco Pascarella / United Soccer League

It’s the sort of stage every young player has dreams about playing on.

While Arsenal’s Emirates Stadium wasn’t close to capacity on February 23, 2023, for Cambridge United academy player George Scales, the atmosphere provided by almost 8,000 fans – nearly 3,000 of which had followed Cambridge’s U-18s to North London – in the Quarterfinals of the 2022-23 FA Youth Cup gave a sense of what the future could hold.

“That’s been the best year of my life in football, on and off the pitch,” Scales said recently. “It was so enjoyable playing in every stadium, especially playing at the Emirates. I mean, we had 3,000 in the away end in a big crowd, and then you just get a taste for what it could be, professional football, full time. Yeah, it was very good, a very good experience.”

A Cambridge native, Scales had joined United’s Academy as a 15-year-old aiming to make it in the professional ranks with his hometown club. That season, Cambridge punched above its weight in the FA Youth Cup, defeating Sheffield Wednesday and Chelsea U-18s in the deepest run the club had made in the tournament in its history. The U’s eventually fell 3-2 to Arsenal on a goal in second-half stoppage time, but the night was one to remember.

Scales went on to make his First Team debut in November, 2023, as one of the club’s Scholars – the equivalent of players competing in the USL Championship or League One as a USL Academy signing. He played the full 90 minutes in a 4-1 win against Tottenham Hotspur’s U-21 side in the EFL Trophy.


George Scales competing for Cambridge United's Academy squad prior to his release from the club after the conclusion of his Scholarship contract. | Photo courtesy Cambridge United

But as his Scholarship term came to an end, reality hit. Unlike a couple of his U-18s teammates, a professional deal to join Cambridge’s First Team squad wasn’t on the cards.

“It's a big disappointment, especially because I think I've done very well there,” said Scales. “But there’s always reasons and footballing opinions. So, you just can’t get too down. You just have to crack on, go again, and literally just believe in yourself. I’ve had knockdowns before that, so I’ve just got to keep getting back up.”

For a large percentage of players who grow up in professional academies in England and elsewhere around Europe, the odds of earning a pro deal are long. After starting at Bradford City’s Academy as an eight-year-old, Dylan Wilkinson found himself in the same position after injuries hampered his progress late in his Academy career with the Bantams.

“It's obviously ideal playing for the city you were born in,” said Wilkinson. “Obviously, I loved it, couldn’t say a bad thing about it, really. They developed me as a footballer and also as a person.

“[Being told your time at the club is over,] it’s not what any kid wants to hear. As bad as it sounds, you’ve worked your full life for that opportunity, and then to get turned away, it’s difficult. But you’ve got to be resilient, not only as a footballer, but as a person, and them decisions are what make and break you.”

For both Wilkinson and Scales, the next opportunity in the game could lie in the United States. Alongside a collection of other former Scholars from EFL Championship, League One and League Two clubs, they’re currently taking the opportunity to showcase their talents as part of a new partnership between the USL and the English Football League and League Football Education (LFE).

The squad’s trip to Florida as part of the 2024 Turing Scheme includes showcase games at the 2024 USL Academy League Finals this week at IMG Academy. It’s also offering players a chance to visit local colleges with the potential they could move to the United States in the fall to compete in NCAA soccer or earn a chance at a contract with a club in the USL Championship or League One.

Over the past two decades it’s become a well-worn path for English players, a strong contingent of which can currently be found on rosters in Major League Soccer, the USL Championship and USL League One, as well as in college soccer.

Among them is current Tampa Bay Rowdies midfielder Lewis Hilton, who was a guest speaker to the squad when they visited the Rowdies’ facility last week.

The scenario facing the players is one that’s familiar to Hilton, who came up through Exeter City’s ranks before attending Hartpury College. During his time at Hartpury, Hilton also trained with Forest Green Rovers, but never entered the professional ranks and came to the United States to play collegiately.

After attracting attention Stateside competing for Young Harris College and in USL League Two, he’s now preparing to enter his 10th season as a professional in the USL Championship in 2025.


Current Tampa Bay Rowdies midfielder Lewis Hilton (left) speaks with two of the former EFL Scholars currently in Florida seeking a new pathway in their professional aspirations. | Photo courtesy Gianmarco Pascarella / United Soccer League

“Everyone’s dream is to play in England,” said Hilton of his path. “When that doesn’t happen, especially at that age, it’s hard to see what the next step is. Do you have to drop down levels in the English pyramid, play part-time and get a job?

“But, to see the opportunities out here to continue playing full-time football? I think it’s definitely eye-opening for them to see, yeah, there is a clear opportunity for them to carry on and play at a really high level. It might be the college system, or it might be coming straight into the USL Championship or League One.”

Hearing from a player with Hilton’s experience was something both Scales and Wilkinson appreciated.

“Obviously, it’s a very different pathway to the traditional way you come through in the English academies,” said Wilkinson. “It just shows that if you’re willing to put the graft in, if you’re willing to take the opportunities when they come to you, good things can come of it. He’s obviously a very talented individual. He’s worked hard at college, and once that opportunity has been given to him, he’s taken it. It shows that if you take the same opportunities, then you could be in a similar position to him.”

Having recently marked his 250th regular season appearance in the USL Championship, Hilton is among the league’s all-time appearance leaders. He’s also built a life away from the field since moving to the United States as an 18-year-old, including an upcoming wedding in January to his American fiancée.

But the USL Championship and League One have more recently begun offering pathways back across the Atlantic. A trio of alums can currently be found in EFL League One, where former USL Championship players Tola Showumni and Jeremy Kelly are with Crawley Town after moves in the past 12 months from Louisville City FC and FC Tulsa respectively, while Nick Akoto is with Burton Albion after his move from South Georgia Tormenta FC in USL League One.


Since his move to Crawley Town in January, former USL Championship player Jeremy Kelly has become a regular in the starting lineup for the current EFL League One club. | Photo courtesy Crawley Town FC

Add the moves being made by players during the summer and winter transfer windows to clubs in other countries in Europe, and there’s now a visible level of opportunity to build a career in both leagues that continues to rise.

For Hilton, it’s a sign of how the leagues are growing and the rising standard of quality that can be found for players aiming to make their mark.

“That shows the level of player that’s in the USL Championship,” said Hilton. “Now you get more and more players making that jump to Europe, it just validates the standard of the USL Championship. It’s great to see it become bigger in the world soccer market.”

For players like Wilkinson and Scales, finding their way into that space is the ultimate goal of their trip to the United States. As enjoyable as the opportunity to broaden their horizons might be – bonding on the field through soccer has brought out the personalities of the players off the field, leading to new friendships being formed and a visible camaraderie within the group – the aim is focused on finding the next step in their ambition to build a professional career in the game.


Photo courtesy Gianmarco Pascarella / United Soccer League

“When things like this get put on the plate for you, you’ve got to take [advantage],” said Wilkinson. “Obviously, it’s difficult. You’re away from your family for a few weeks. And if things go well, it’s not a few weeks, it could be a few years, so you’ve got to be strong mentally. You’ve got to make the sacrifices being away from your family, being away from your friends.

“But ultimately, if you want to make it as a footballer in whatever country it is, you’re going to make sacrifices.”

The road ahead might not lead to Emirates Stadium, but it could result in the sort of professional adventure young players will always aspire to.

“The main focus is the football, and hopefully getting a chance over here,” said Scales. “Whether it be getting a trial and at the end of it, going into that with hope, playing to my full potential and getting an offer over here, that is the main target.”

“It would be nice to get an opportunity.”

Follow the USL Championship

Most Recent News

Most Read News

Latest Videos